Court Dismisses PDP Suit Against Benue Lawmaker, Hon. Anthony Attah Agom

The Federal High Court in Abuja has dismissed a suit filed by the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) seeking to remove the Member representing Okpokwu State Constituency in the Benue State House of Assembly, Rt. Hon. Anthony Attah Agom, JP, from office following his defection to the All Progressives Congress (APC).

Delivering judgment on Tuesday in suit FHC/ABJ/CS/2408/2025, Justice Muhammed Umar ruled that although Hon. Agom admitted defecting from the PDP to the APC, the court could not assume the constitutional powers vested in the Speaker and the Benue State House of Assembly to declare his seat vacant.

The PDP had instituted the suit against the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), the APC, and Hon. Agom, asking the court to determine whether votes cast for a political party could be transferred to another party after a legislator defects.

The party also sought declarations that Hon. Agom’s continued occupation of the seat after leaving the PDP was unlawful, that all legislative actions he participated in after his defection should be declared null and void, and that he should refund all salaries, allowances, and privileges received since joining the APC.

In his judgment, Justice Umar noted that the central issue before the court was Hon. Agom’s defection, which the lawmaker did not deny. However, he held that the constitutional process required to declare a legislative seat vacant had not been followed.

According to the judge, the mere announcement of a legislator’s defection is insufficient to trigger the loss of a seat. He explained that under Section 109 of the 1999 Constitution (as amended), the Benue State House of Assembly must first declare the seat vacant, after which the Speaker is required to notify INEC to conduct a bye-election.

Justice Umar stated that until those constitutional steps are taken, INEC has no authority to act, stressing that the court could not usurp the powers assigned to the Speaker or members of the House of Assembly.

While the court rejected the preliminary objection challenging the competence of the suit, holding that the originating summons disclosed a reasonable cause of action, it ultimately dismissed the substantive case.

Justice Umar concluded that the PDP’s application lacked merit and accordingly dismissed the suit.

Ebony9ja Media

A blogger and a social media influencer

Recent Posts

LABOUR PARTY CRISIS: FRANCIS NART CHALLENGES PURPORTED SUSPENSION, ACCUSES PARTY LEADERS OF DOUBLE STANDARDS IN BENUE

  Comrade Nart Eche Francis, the Labour Party Chairman of Otukpo Local Government Area of…

2 days ago

FRANCIS NART REJECTS PURPORTED SUSPENSION AS LABOUR PARTY CHAIRMAN OF OTUKPO

  The Labour Party Chairman of Otukpo Local Government Area of Benue State, Comrade Nart…

2 days ago

BREAKING: BENUE ENTERTAINER, ‘BENUE CHRIS BROWN’, REPORTEDLY SH0T DEAD; MOTORCYCLE STOLEN

  The Benue entertainment industry has reportedly been thrown into mourning following the alleged killing…

3 days ago

AGADA ON ARISE TV: ALIA BROUGHT KADUNA-BASED CAR DEALER BENJAMIN OMALE TO TAKE OVER BENUE APC LEADERSHIP

  The lingering leadership crisis within the Benue State chapter of the All Progressives Congress…

3 days ago

BENUE APC CRISIS: AGADA ACCUSES GOVERNOR ALIA OF OWING HIM ₦19.7 MILLION, QUESTIONS UNPAID INHERITED SALARY ARREARS

  The factional Chairman of the All Progressives Congress (APC) in Benue State, Dr Austin…

4 days ago

CHIEF DR. BENJAMIN OMALE: THE POLITICAL HEAVYWEIGHT, MASTER STRATEGIST AND STABILISING FORCE BEHIND BENUE APC

  In politics, some leaders command attention through grand displays, while others earn influence through…

5 days ago